Search
Search for:
in
 


Featured Articles
Looking for Holistic MD/DO

Introduction to Traditional Osteopathy

Overdue: Natural Approach to Inducing Labor

Homeopathic Pre-labor Protocol for Easier Childbirth

Ultrasound and Pregnancy

Tips on How to Achieve a Natural Healthy Pregnancy and Birth

Vaginal Birth and Gut Flora; A Reason to Not Choose a C-Section

The Medicalization of Childbirth

Homeopathic Medicine for Easier Childbirth

Healthcare and Wisdom from the Ages: The Best of Both Worlds

On Being Tongue-Tied

Flu Treatment SOS

Fever: What to Do

The Wonderful Uses of Homeopathy

Pertussis (Whooping Cough)

Natural Treatments for Cough

Conventional Treatment of Coughs

A New Look at an Old Diet: 12 Tips (infants to adults)

Autism: General Health Tips

Amniocentesis

Immune Boosters FAQ

Natural and Homeopathic Prevention During Travel

Homeopathic Medicine: Directions for Use

Recommended Remedies Before and After the Shot

Homeopathy for Travel and Camping

Homeopathic Treatment for Jaundice

Boost the Immune System During the Flu Season, Naturally

Gemmotherapy Herbs for Cold and Flu

The Healing Effects of Onion

 

Vitamix

Juice Plus+

Articles : A to Z Conditions (including Pertussis)
  
H1N1 Swine Flu Shot Update: Back to Articles
by Jay Gordon, MD, FAAP

I have seen more children and adults with influenza-like illness: 104 degree fevers, muscle soreness, sore throat and negative tests for strep, than in any summer I can remember. I haven't used the "flu swab" to test anybody, but I'm sure that many if not most of these sick people had Swine Flu. They all felt miserable, and they are all feeling just fine now.

Preventing outbreaks of this "novel H1N1" influenza may be a mistake of huge proportions. Yes, sadly, there will be fatalities among the 6 billion citizens of the planet. Tens of millions of cases of any illness will lead to morbidity and mortality, but this is completely (tragically) unavoidable. The consequences of not acquiring immunity this time around, however, could be really terrible and far outweigh a mass prevention program.

Here's my rationale for not using Tamiflu:  If (if, if, if) this virus circles the globe as the rather innocent influenza it now appears to be, but mutates and returns as a very virulent form of influenza, it will be quite wonderful and life-saving to have formed antibodies against its 2009 version. These antibodies may be far from 100% protective, but they will help. This is incredibly important but being ignored in the interest of expediency. 

In 1918, it appears that influenza A (an H1N1, by the way) did this globe-trotting mutation and killed millions. The times and state of medical care are not comparable, but a milder parallel occurrence is possible. Perhaps this happens every 100 years or so, perhaps every three million.

Whenever possible, we should form antibodies against viruses at the right stage of their existence and at the right stage of our lives (For example, chickenpox in childhood and EBV/mono in early childhood. There are many other examples.) Getting many viral illnesses confers lifetime immunity, and very few vaccines do.
 
Tamiflu is a very powerful drug with little proven efficacy against this bug, and with its major side effect being tummy upset. I'm not using it at all. Psychiatric side effects are also possible.

I also won't be giving the flu shot to the kids and parents in my practice unless there are extraordinary risk factors.  I anticipate giving none at all this year.  I doubt that there will be any really large problems with the vaccine, but I also doubt any really large benefits. As I said, I think that this year's version of this particular H1N1 is as "mild" as it will ever be and that getting sick with it this year will be good rather than bad.  The chances that a new "flu shot" will be overwhelmingly effective are small.  

I consider this, and most seasonal and novel influenza A vaccines, as "experimental" vaccines; they've only been tested on thousands of people for a period of weeks and then they'll be given to hundreds of millions of people. Not really the greatest science when we're in that much of a hurry. Yes, one can measure antibodies against a certain bacterium or virus in the blood and it may be associated with someone not getting sick, but there are very few illnesses common enough or enough ethics committees willing enough to do the right tests.  That is, give 1000 people the real vaccine and 1000 placebo shots, expose all of them to the disease and see who gets sick.  Seriously. I know it sounds terrible.

This is, obviously, a difficult public discussion because it touches on the concept of benefits and risks, again, of morbidity and mortality. Few public officials have the courage or inclination to present all facets of this difficult decision. I give vaccines to my patients every single day, but I always err on the side of caution. Implying that this is a dangerous new shot is not scientifically or statistically correct and represents hyperbole and even dishonesty on the part of the so-called "anti-vaccine" camp. 

It sure isn't "sexy" to suggest handwashing, good nutrition, hydration, extra sleep and so on. It's not conventional to suggest astragalus, echinacea, elderberry and vitamin C. Adequate vitamin D levels are crucial, too.

I just think that giving this new H1N1 vaccine is not the cautious nor best thing to do.
  
Best,

Jay Gordon, MD FAAP


 


 
My Shopping Cart
You have 0 items in your cart.

Sub-Total: $ 0.00

View Cart    Checkout

 

FREE Newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter for monthly natural health features and site updates for you and your family!

 

Featured Products

Boiron Homeopathy Family Kit

$ 99.99

Boiron Homeopathy Travel Kit

$ 74.99

Herbal Ear Drops:

$ 12.95

Natural Baby and Childcare

$ 19.95

The Parents' Concise Guide to Childhood Vaccinations

$ 12.95

Vitamin C for Children

$ 11.95

Teething Necklace

$ 19.99

Carlson's Vitamin D Drops 400 IU

$ 15.95

Natural Pregnancy JUST ARRIVED!

$ 14.95

Pelvic Floor Hoangs

$ 39.95

NouYou2

$ 28.95

Introduction to Osteopathy Booklet

$ 9.95

Winter Balance

$ 18.95
 

The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment.
All content, including text, graphics, images and information, contained on or available through this web site is for general information purposes only.